Alliance for Excellent Education
Association for Middle Level Education
National Association of Secondary School Principals
National Forum to Accelerate Middle-Grades Reform
with
Honorary Co-hosts
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (RI)
Rep. Raúl Grijalva (AZ-7)
INVITE YOU TO
A SPECIAL BRIEFING
Early Warning Indicator Systems:
A Tool for High Performing Middle Grades Schools
This briefing will discuss the impact of using early warning indicator systems—which identify students at high risk of dropping out as early as sixth grade—to keep students on track for graduation and accelerate successful student progress. Hear from representatives from a middle school, the research community, and Congressional staff.
Wednesday, June 20, 2012
3:30 PM – 4:30 PM
HC-8 in the Capitol
*Please bring identification for entrance via the House side of Capitol *
Presenters Include
Bob Wise, President
Alliance for Excellent Education
Bob Balfanz, Co-director, Everyone Graduates Center
Johns Hopkins University
Catherine Miller, Teacher and Data Specialist
MS 244, The New School for Leadership and the Arts
Bronx, NY
Regan Fitzgerald, Legislative Counsel
Senator Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)
|
RSVP to: Ellen Fern – efern@wpllc.net
Renewing an effort to strengthen middle level education as a way to increase high school graduation rates, Rep. Raúl Grijalva (D-AZ) and Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) have reintroduced the Success in the Middle Act (H.R. 1547/S. 833).
“This bill recognizes the role of the middle grades as a tipping point in the education of many of our nation’s students, especially those who are at risk of dropping out,” said Sen. Whitehouse in a statement on the Senate floor upon the bill’s introduction. “Success in the Middle invests much-needed attention and resources in middle grades education, requiring states to create plans to specifically address the unique needs of students in the age group, and focusing on schools that feed into some of our country’s most dropout-prone high schools so they are ready for the curriculum and the unique social pressures they will encounter there.”
NASSP worked with the National Middle School Association, the National Forum to Accelerate Middle Grades Reform, and a number of other education groups to draft the Success in the Middle Act, and the bill incorporates many of the recommendations outlined in Breaking Ranks in the Middle. Specifically, the bill would:
In an effort to improve high school graduation rates, House Education and Labor Committee Chairman George Miller (D-CA) and other Democratic leaders have introduced legislation aimed at turning around the nation’s “dropout factories” and their feeder middle schools.
“We are failing our students, failing our communities and failing our nation if we allow this dropout crisis to continue,” said Miller in a press release about the Graduation for All Act (H.R. 4122). “Ending this epidemic is a civil rights imperative, a moral issue and an economic necessity. This bill says that it is no longer acceptable to let an at-risk student fall through the cracks and empowers schools to make changes needed to help at-risk students thrive in school, earn a diploma and go on to college or a good job.”
Under Title I, the bill would authorize a $2 billion competitive grant program for districts to support high schools with a graduation rate of 65 percent or lower and their feeder middle schools. Specifically, participating districts would implement a “Model of Success” in secondary schools similar to the four school intervention models outlined in the School Improvement Grants program:
Transformation Model, which includes increasing teacher and school leader effectiveness through mentoring and induction programs and career-ladder opportunities;
Turnaround Model, which includes 1) replacing the principal if student achievement has declined during his or her tenure; and 2) replacing or reassigning teachers who do not have subject-matter expertise in the subjects they teach or are not highly qualified
Restart Model, which includes closing a school and reopening it under a school management organization or charter management organization; and
Close-Down Model, which includes closing a school and re-enrolling students in other, higher-achieving schools in the district.
The legislation would require districts to implement an early warning system to identify students at risk of dropping out and provide them with academic and social supports to help them succeed—a concept endorsed by NASSP and embodied in the Success in the Middle Act and the Graduation Promise Act (GPA). Finally, districts would provide school leadership teams with more operating flexibility with respect to staffing, budgets, scheduling, and use of school-time decisions; establish credit-recovery programs; and enhance college and career counseling in secondary schools.
Title II of the bill would authorize $150 million for schools districts to partner with local colleges or universities in establishing an early college high school or other dual enrollment program; and Title III would facilitate research on effective best practices to improve student achievement in the middle grades.
“While NASSP is pleased that Congress is focusing attention on middle level and high schools as part of its reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, we are concerned that the Graduation for All Act emphasizes four school reform models whose success remains untested and unproven,” said NASSP Executive Director Gerald N. Tirozzi. “We will continue to advocate for legislation that promotes genuine school improvement and encompasses the Breaking Ranks framework, including the Success in the Middle Act and GPA.”
Renewing an effort to strengthen middle level education as a way to increase high school graduation rates, Congressman Raúl Grijalva (D-AZ) and Sen. Jack Reed (D-RI) have reintroduced the Success in the Middle Act (H.R. 3006/S. 1362). Although there was strong support to pass the legislation as part of the reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, action on all education bills was postponed during the 110th Congress.
“Middle schools are a forgotten area,” said Congressman Grijalva. “We need to invest in the most crucial years of the education pipeline to ensure our students succeed. Middle school students are faced with many changes in their personal life and the pressures of adjusting into teenagers. Our schools need to invest in this transitional period, to create the support mechanism these students will need to continue through high school and on to other higher education opportunities.”
“There has been significant focud during K-12 reform discussions regarding high school reform, and while there is no doubt that this is an essential component of improving our education system, addressing dropout prevention must begin earlier,” said Sen. Reed in a statement on the Senate floor. “As one of the leading experts in the area of middle and high school reform, Robert Balfanz has stated, middle schools are the ‘first line of defense’ in identifying at-risk students and then effectively intervening to prevent them from dropping out.”
NASSP worked with the National Middle School Association, the National Forum to Accelerate Middle Grades Reform, and a number of other education groups to draft the Success in the Middle Act, and the bill incorporates many of the recommendations outlined in Breaking Ranks in the Middle. Specifically, the bill would:
- Authorize $1 billion annually for grants to local school districts to improve low-performing schools that contain middle grades.
- Require states receiving grants to implement a plan that describes what students are required to know and do to successfully complete the middle grades and transition to and succeed in an academically rigorous high school that prepares them for postsecondary education and the workplace
- Require states to develop early warning and intervention systems to identify those students most at-risk of dropping out and intervene appropriately to help them succeed.
- Encourage states and districts to invest in proven strategies, such as: 1) Providing professional development and coaching to school leaders, teachers and other school personnel in addressing the needs of diverse learners and in using challenging and relevant research-based best practices and curriculum; 2) Developing and implementing comprehensive, school-wide improvement efforts in eligible schools; and 3) Implementing student supports, such as extended learning time and personal academic plans that enable all students to stay on the path to graduation.
- Authorizes an additional $100 million to facilitate the generation, dissemination, and application of research to identify promising practices in middle grades education, as well as review existing research on middle grades education practices.
Take action! As a school leader, you are in a prime position to educate your members of Congress about the needs of middle level schools and their students. Please visit the Principal’s Legislative Action Center and urge your representative and senators to cosponsor the Success in the Middle Act.
The level of academic achievement that students attain by eighth grade has a larger impact on college and career readiness than anything that happens academically in high school, according to a report released in December by ACT. The Forgotten Middle examines the specific academic and nonacademic factors that influence postsecondary success and how these factors have a greatest impact during a student’s educational development.
“NASSP has long recognized the important role middle level education plays in preparing students for their future, and this report should serve as a call to action for national attention and a national initiative to support students in the middle grades” said NASSP Executive Director Gerald N. Tirozzi. “We believe that The Forgotten Middle, especially when coupled with the early identification and effective intervention research done at Johns Hopkins University, sends a clear and urgent message to policymakers that the middle level can no longer be ignored. If we want to improve the graduation rate in our nation and give all students an opportunity for postsecondary education, we cannot wait until high school to begin that work.”
The ACT report analyzed data from approximately 216,000 students in the 2005 and 2006 high school graduation classes who had taken all three programs included in the longitudinal assessment component of the ACT College Readiness System: EXPLORE (grades 8-9), PLAN (grade 10), and the ACT test (grades 11-12). By measuring the four EXPLORE scores in English, mathematics, reading, and science, the study shows that “eighth-grade achievement displays a stronger relationship with eleventh- or twelfth-grade ACT scores, and therefore with college and career readiness, than does any other factor—more than students’ family background, high school coursework, or high school grade point average.” Similar results were found for racial/ethnic minority students and also when data was analyzed by students’ annual family income level.
ACT also collected data from students at 24 middle level schools throughout the nation to examine the role that academically related psychosocial factors play in predicting course failure in the eighth grade and high school grade point average in the ninth grade—two important indicators in predicting future academic success in. The ten factors were academic discipline, commitment, family attitude, family involvement, optimism, orderly conduct, relationships with school personnel, school safety, steadiness, and thinking before acting. The findings showed that academic discipline and orderly conduct both had a “substantial impact” on course failure in the eighth grade, and the same factors combined with having positive relationships with school personnel greatly impacted grade point average in the ninth grade.
The Forgotten Middle outlines 55 nonnegotiable knowledge and skills that all eighth-grade students must have in order to be on target for college and career readiness: 7 in English, 26 in mathematics, 6 in reading, and 16 in science. According to the report, the standards serve as instructional links and “should be used to articulate skills and courses among elementary school and middle school and between middle school and high school.”
Finally, ACT offers recommendations to improve academic achievement and college and career readiness for all middle level and high school students:
- Focus K-8 standards on the knowledge and skills that are essential for college and career readiness, and make these knowledge and skills nonnegotiable for all students
- Monitor student progress in becoming ready for college and career, and intervene with students who are not on target to becoming ready, beginning in upper elementary school and continuing through middle school
- Improve students’ academic behavior
- Increase federal and state support for schools to implement intervention programs that help all students become ready for college and career
The Forgotten Middle clearly points to the need for a federal investment in middle level education as outlined in the Success in the Middle Act, a bill introduced last year by President-Elect Barack Obama (D-IL) and Rep. Raul Grijalva (D-AZ).Outlining many of the policy recommendations made in Breaking Ranks in the Middle, the legislation would authorize $1 billion to support states in creating middle school improvement plans, implement early warning identification systems for students most at risk of dropping out, and invest in proven interventions to help all middle level students succeed.
To read the full ACT report, go to www.act.org.
Middle schools are garnering national attention and could become a key issue in the 2008 presidential election now that Sen. Barack Obama (D-IL) has introduced the Success in the Middle Act (S. 2227). The legislation is nearly identical to a bill (H.R. 3406) introduced by Rep. Raúl Grijalva (D-AZ) in September.
“For far too long, our education system has overlooked our nation’s middle schools and failed to provide them the resources they need for our kids to succeed,” said Sen. Obama. “The middle school experience is vital to success in high school and college, and the lack of attention to middle school on a federal level is reflected in the rising high school dropout rate…We need to do more to invest in these schools, and this legislation will invest in a new generation of leaders by strengthening our middle schools, teachers, and students. If our country wants to remain competitive in math and science on a global level, we must break down any barriers that are preventing our kids from getting the world-class education they deserve.”
NASSP joined forces earlier this year with National Middle School Association, the National Forum to Accelerate Middle-Grades Reform, and a number of other education associations to form the Middle Grades Coalition on NCLB. The coalition promoted joint recommendations for NCLB reauthorization and drafted the Success in the Middle Act, which reflects NASSP Policy Recommendations for Middle Level Reform. Specifically, the bill would:
- Authorize $1 billion for formula grants to states to help local school districts improve low-performing schools that contain middle grades
- Require states receiving a grant to implement a statewide plan for improving student achievement in the middle grades
- Ensure that statewide plans describe what students are required to know to successfully complete the middle grades and make the transition to succeed in an academically rigorous high school
that prepares students for postsecondary education and the workplace - Require states and districts to develop an early identification data system to identify those students most at risk of dropping out, and to help school districts provide proven interventions to help all middle level students succeed
- Ensure that states and districts invest in proven intervention strategies such as 1) providing professional development and coaching to enable school leaders, teachers, and other school personnel address the needs of diverse learners and use challenging and relevant research-based best practices and curriculum; 2) developing and implementing comprehensive, schoolwide improvement efforts in our nation’s lowest-performing schools; 3) and implementing student supports, such as extended learning time, personal academic plans, and intensive reading and math instruction that enable all students to stay on the path to graduation
- Authorize an additional $100 million for research to identify and implement effective practices that lead to student learning and success at the middle level
“Students in grades 5 through 8 represent 57% (14 million) of the nation’s annual test takers under the No Child Left Behind Act, but middle schools are not receiving adequate federal funding and support to help these students succeed,” said NASSP Executive Director Gerald N. Tirozzi. “The Success in the Middle Act would provide the support necessary to turn around our nation’s lowest-performing middle schools and give our struggling students the help they need to achieve in high school, college, and beyond.”
Patti Kinney, the recently appointed director of NASSP’s National Center for Middle Level Leadership said, “It is very exciting and gratifying to see that Congress is finally beginning to realize the importance of middle level education. Without programs and support directed specifically toward this level, our nation will be unable to meet the provisions of No Child Left Behind and provide all young adolescents with a challenging, engaging education that prepares them for a successful future.”
The House and Senate sponsors of the Success in the Middle Act are working diligently to incorporate the bill into NCLB, but reauthorization will likely be postponed until spring 2008 at the earliest.
Take action! As a school leader, you are in a prime position to educate your members of Congress about the needs of middle level schools and their students. Please visit the Principal’s Legislative Action Center and urge your senators to cosponsor the Success in the Middle Act.
Middle level reform is finally receiving national attention now that Rep. Raúl Grijalva (D-AZ) has introduced the Success in the Middle Act (H.R. 3406). The bill, which would create a Middle Schools Improvement Fund, will likely be incorporated into the reauthorization of the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB).
“Middle schools are a forgotten area in this whole NCLB reauthorization process,” Grijalva said in a press release announcing the bill’s introduction. “We need to invest in the most crucial years of the education pipeline to ensure our students succeed.”
The Success in the Middle Act was drafted by NASSP in collaboration with National Middle School Association, the National Forum to Accelerate Middle-Grades Reform, and a number of other education organizations. The groups joined forces earlier this year to promote joint recommendations for NCLB reauthorization, and the Grijalva bill is a key piece of the agenda to improve middle level education. Specifically, the bill would:
- Authorize $1 billion for the Middle Schools Improvement Fund to help local school districts improve low-performing schools that contain middle grades
- Require states receiving a grant to implement a statewide plan for improving student achievement in the middle grades
- Ensure that statewide plans describe what students are required to know to successfully complete the middle grades and succeed in an academically rigorous high school that prepares students for postsecondary education and the workplace
- Require states and districts to develop an early-warning data system to identify those students most at risk of dropping out and implement interventions that will help those students succeed
- Ensure that states and districts invest in proven intervention strategies such as providing professional development and coaching for school leaders, teachers, and other school personnel to address the needs of diverse learners and use challenging and relevant research-based best practices and curricula; and developing and implementing comprehensive, schoolwide improvement efforts in the nation’s lowest-performing schools; and implementing student supports such as personal academic plans, mentoring, intensive reading and math instruction, and extended learning time, which help all students to stay on the path to graduation
- Authorize an additional $100 million dollars to facilitate the generation, dissemination, and application of research to identify and implement effective practices that lead to continual student learning and high academic achievement at the middle level.
The future success of NCLB rests largely on the shoulders of middle level leaders, teachers, and students. Students in grades 5 through 8 represent 57% (14 million) of the nation’s annual test takers, but students are leaving middle level schools underprepared for the rigorous academic and social demands of successful high school participation and completion. NASSP firmly believes that the Success in the Middle Act will ensure greater academic achievement in high school, lower dropout rates, higher graduation rates, and more students attending college in the future.
Take action! The House Education and Labor Committee is moving quickly on NCLB reauthorization and plans to mark up a bill when Congress returns from its summer recess in September. As a school leader, you are in a prime position to educate your members of Congress about the needs of middle level schools and their students. Visit the Principal’s Legislative Action Center (www.nassp.org/PLAC) and urge your members of Congress to cosponsor the Success in the Middle Act.



